This isn’t amateur hour
From The GIST College Sports (hi@thegistsports.com)
Hey, hey!
No. 2 Iowa superstar Caitlin Clark probably won’t drop 66 points to break the NCAA women’s hoops scoring record tomorrow at 9 p.m. ET…but you might want to watch just in case. Even when she’s not making history (yet), she’s must-see TV.
— Tulane sports law professor Gabe Feldman, aka @SportsLawGuy, on the new ruling from the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) declaring Dartmouth’s men’s basketball players are school employees. Looks like some athletes will be riding that wave all the way to the bank.
NCAA amateurism challenges
🏛️ This isn’t amateur hour
The GIST: On Monday, a NLRB regional director ruled that under U.S. labor law, Dartmouth’s men’s basketball team members are considered the school’s employees, the first nail in the coffin for the NCAA’s beleaguered amateurism model.
How we got here: In September 2023, the 15 Dartmouth teammates filed a petition with the NLRB to unionize, hoping to be reclassified as employees to receive compensation and healthcare benefits (especially considering Ivy League schools don’t offer athletic scholarships). In an op-ed for the student paper, the players referred to the current model as a “brazen exploitation of athlete labor.”
- And the Big Green aren’t alone in challenging the status quo: Several groups are currently pursuing paydays and other worker protections from their institutions.
What it means: As employees, Dartmouth’s men’s hoopers now have entitlements to wages, healthcare benefits, and other employment standards, including the right to unionize. More importantly, nothing prevents every Division I (DI) athlete from pursuing a similar setup.
- In response, Dartmouth argued it can’t afford to pay its athletes and will likely appeal to the NLRB’s national board, which notably blocked Northwestern football players’ 2014 unionization attempt. But that denial was based on a technicality, which may not apply here.
What’s next: If the ruling holds, the precedent would signal the end of the amateurism model as we know it. What does this mean for female athletes? Critics worry that added expenses of athlete wages will sink women’s and nonrevenue sports like gymnastics, soccer, and more.
- But Title IX — which requires schools to provide equal opportunities based on sex — still protects female athletes, so for now, there’s nothing to do but watch this space.
Softball
🥎 Dirt in the skirt!
The GIST: Dust off your visor and oil your glove — the NCAA softball season officially starts tomorrow, with 301 DI teams vying for the chance to compete at spring’s premier event, the Women’s College World Series (WCWS).
Teams to know: Surprising absolutely no one, Oklahoma is the preseason No. 1 as they chase their fourth straight (!!!) national title. But the Sooners look a little different this year after losing the reigning WCWS Most Outstanding Player, pitcher Jordy Bahl, to the transfer portal and bringing in an all-star class of freshmen and transfers to fill her cleats.
- If Oklahoma is Regina George, No. 4 Florida State is Gretchen Wieners. The Sooners beat FSU in two of the last three WCWS, but with six of Florida State’s seven top hitters returning, roster stability could give the Seminoles the edge this season.
- Other powerhouses to look out for include No. 2 Tennessee and No. 3 Stanford, but the dark horse? No. 17 Nebraska. The Cornhuskers shocked the world when the aforementioned Bahl joined them in the offseason, single-handedly putting the program on the map in the process.
What to watch: There are tons of tournaments to start the season, but the spiciest matchups go down at the Puerto Vallarta College Challenge: Oklahoma takes on No. 9 Duke at 2 p.m. ET, and Nebraska faces No. 10 Washington at 7:30 p.m. ET. Catch both games on FloSoftball, then settle in for a season full of dingers.
🏀 Men’s basketball
The mighty just keep falling: Two of this weekend’s most triumphant teams suffered upsets in the last 48 hours. First, on Monday, No. 4 Kansas’ rebounding troubles earned the squad a humbling 75–70 road loss to intrastate rival Kansas State, snapping the Wildcats’ four-game losing streak in the process. Oof.
- Then, last night, Clemson outdueled No. 3 UNC’s elite frontcourt of Armando Bacot and Harrison Ingram 80–75 to nab their second road win at UNC…ever. Hot damn.
🏒 Men’s ice hockey
No. 3 Boston University avenged last week’s Green Line Rivalry loss by beating No. 1 Boston College 4–3 in Monday’s semifinals of the Beanpot, an annual tournament for Boston’s four top hockey schools. Nothing they do better.
- In the other Beanpot semi, a surging Northeastern squad captured an overtime win over Harvard to advance. Given the Huskies upset BU just last week, next Monday’s final is going to be doubly dramatic.
Peep our squad’s MVPs (Most Valuable Picks):
📚 What to read
Us Against You by Fredrik Backman for The GIST Book Club. A sequel to last year’s pick, Beartown, the town is struck with another tough blow with the news that their local hockey team will soon be disbanded. Read with us on Fable today.
🏀 Who keeps impressing
No. 2 Iowa women's basketball superstar Caitlin Clark, of course. From the men in the stands to the men who practice against her, she’s proving to all her opponents that she’s a force to be reckoned with.
🎶 Who to listen to
Maggie Rogers. The singer-songwriter has new music dropping tomorrow, and it’s sure to cure any winter blues.
Today's email was brought to you by Katie Kehoe Foster, Ruth Lenzen, Dee Lab, and Briana Ekanem. Editing by Lindsay Jost and Isabella Troia. Fact checking by Mikaela Perez. Ops by Lisa Minutillo and Elisha Gunaratnam. Ads by Katie Kehoe Foster, Lauren Tuiskula, and Dee Lab. Managing edits by Ellen Hyslop.